But does it actually work?
The answer to that question is a massive “maybe”
with a large dose of "it might do more harm than good.”
The Rooney Rule is the idea that to tackle the
lack of diversity in an organization at least one person from a diverse
background should be shortlisted to be interviewed for certain jobs.
This week ITN revealed that on average
its BAME staff roughly receive 20% less pay than their white counterparts.
When it comes to bonuses the figures are
even worse with BAME employees receiving roughly two thirds less than
their white colleagues.
To tackle the problem ITN immediately
announced it will be implementing a version of the Rooney Rule, their exact
words were; “A key initiative, effective immediately, includes the policy for
at least one BAME candidate to be interviewed for every role.”
Similarly just a month earlier (almost to
the day) the BBC announced it would be implementing the Rooney Rule with shortlists
for all senior roles at the BBC having to include at least one BAME candidate.
ACADEMICS
SAY THE ROONEY RULE HAS NOT INCREASED DIVERSITY IN THE NFL
So what has been the experience of the
Rooney Rule?
The Rooney Rule is named after the ex-president
of the American Football team the Pittsburgh Steelers – Dan Rooney - who
championed the policy to be adopted by the NFL in an attempt to increase the
number of BAME head coaches.
At the time it was implemented in 2003
there were only three minority head coaches out of the 32 teams. In 2006 the
number of head coaches had more than doubled to seven.
But by 2013 the number had dropped back down
to three.
Last year the number had gone back up to
seven.
And this year despite seven head coach
places becoming free only one BAME coach was appointed.
With the numbers yo-yoing like this the problem
of trying to definitively say whether the Rooney Rule works is very difficult. We are trying to analyse
incredibly small numbers, a few dozen teams and even fewer coaches, and come to a simple answer.
The fact that the policy can be heralded a
success one year because numbers have doubled due to four individual appointments
and then labelled a failure because five years later the numbers have fallen
back to just three shows how difficult it is to judge its
effectiveness.
However when academics have crunched the
numbers the conclusion seems to be that they “find no evidence that the Rooney
Rule has increased the number of minority head coaches.” ("Moving on up: The
Rooney rule and minority hiring in the NFL" published in the
journal Labour Economics).
ROONEY
RULE DOES NOT INCREASE DIVERSITY IF THERE’S JUST ONE MINORITY CANDIDATE
But what the champions of the Rooney Rule claim
is that at least it creates equality of opportunity because BAME candidates get
to be seen and interviewed.
This is a dubious claim.
In a ground
breaking study researchers at the University of Colorado showed that simply
adding one minority candidate to an interview list does not help improve diversity
hiring.
When there is only one minority candidate in
the interview pool the chances of them being hired is close to zero. There are
several theories as to why this may be the case, including the idea that they
are seen as a novelty or an outlier or more of a risk.
However if the number of minorities being
interviewed is doubled to just two then their chances of being hired rockets.
The study showed how the effect is also
true for women being interviewed.
SHOULD
WE SUPPORT BROADCASTERS IMPLEMENTING THE ROONEY RULE?
The very real fear of broadcasters
implementing the Rooney Rule is that it can be counterproductive as managers
feel they are addressing a problem when they more than likely are not.
The business magazine Forbes recently
looked at the issue and it criticized the use of the Rooney Rule of being a
lazy management tool when what is really needed to tackle diversity is “real
investment from senior leadership over a sustained period of time to look at
the root causes of the issues and develop the cultural shift that will bring
success.”
Forbes magazine concludes that if you want
to improve diversity “Don’t implement
the Rooney Rule”.
I wouldn’t go that far as I don’t think there
is conclusive proof either way.
But what there does seem to be conclusive proof about is
adding one minority candidate will not dramatically improve diversity, and so if
you really want to implement the Rooney Rule you must have at least two BAME
candidates short-listed.
No comments:
Post a Comment