Friday, 21 July 2023

Not Holding Power to Account - The Consequence of the Lack of Media Diversity



Back in 2012 the then Duke and Duchess of Rothesay, better known as Prince Charles and Camilla, visited the BBC Scotland Studios in Glasgow to celebrate 60 years of BBC Scotland television. I was head of BBC Scotland Current Affairs programmes at the time and I was duly lined up with other executives in the newsroom to greet them and say a few words about the work we do. After they met staff in the newsroom they filmed a special edition of the weather report in which Charles and Camilla took turns in presenting the forecast.

What I remember most about the royal visit was not what happened on the day but what happened the day after.

The following day Scotland’s then First Minister, Alex Salmond, came to the Glasgow studios and was also given a brief tour. The difference between how the BBC news executives dressed and acted on the two days was marked. On the first day BBC executives greeted the non-elected king-in-waiting dressed in evening suits and ties for the men, and formal dresses for the women. On the second day the same BBC executives meeting the highest elected official in Scotland had reverted to jeans and trainers, and the few who were wearing suit jackets were definitely not wearing ties.

Royalty suits them?

Although my BBC colleagues were fastidious not to discuss their own personal politics at work (the idea of impartiality runs deep in BBC newsrooms) I personally knew that some of the BBC news executives were royalist and others were republicans. I also knew that there were SNP supporters among them as well as well as supporters of other political parties. But irrespective of people’s personal views the overriding culture on display was one in which you showed deference and respect to royalty and relative indifference to elected officials, however high their office.

As one of the few Black people of West Indian heritage working at senior level at the BBC I was more than aware of the ongoing debate that was taking place in the Caribbean about the role of the monarchy. Kenya became a republic in 1964; being married to a Kenyan I understood that Black British people have a very different historical relationship with the royal family. While it’s easy to dismiss fashion choices, the different treatments troubled me, to say the least, as to what it said about the prevailing cross-political culture in the newsroom and who shaped it. For the record, for both visits I dressed in the same smart casual way I usually did every day in the office.

I was reminded of these different treatments recently when I found myself in a discussion with senior news executives from both newspapers and television on how different news outlets had covered the Queen’s funeral.

I said that I thought the domestic coverage in general, and the BBC’s in particular, had been unduly uncritical of the monarchy when one compared it to news coverage elsewhere in the world. The response I received from several executives in the (virtual) room was that the British broadcasters ‘couldn’t have reported on the Queen’s death in any other way’ without being disrespectful, and the period directly following the queen’s death ‘was not the time to be critical’.

Second time round more critical?

There is little doubt that news coverage of the role of the monarchy in Britain has been more critical and questioning in the run up to the Charles III’s coronation than during coverage of the Queen’s death. For example, three weeks before the coronation, BBC Panorama broadcast a programme titled ‘Will King Charles Change the Monarchy?’ The programme shared poll findings that only a minority of people under the age of fifty positively preferred a monarchy to an elected head of state, yet overall 58 per cent of people preferred an unelected monarchy to an elected head of state. BBC Radio 4 also broadcast ‘The Today Debate: Do We Need a Monarchy?’ And other UK broadcasters have had similar programmes critically analysing the role of the monarchy as an institution in UK life and politics.

However, far from making up for a lack of critical coverage during the period of the Queen’s death, all this new coverage highlights a serious journalistic failing.

To use a simple analogy; if the position of King was an elected one, the critical debate and polls around the monarchy now, at the time of the King’s Coronation, feels like having election coverage after all the votes have been cast, the winner has been announced and we’re just deciding where to hold the victory celebrations.

Why? That’s because the period covering the Queen’s death was also the same period as King Charles III’s proclamation and ascension to the throne.

It is that time, not now, that was the critical time in which British journalists should have been asking the difficult questions about the monarchy and fulfilling one of the fundamental principles of journalism, ‘holding power to account’, however inconvenient or unpopular among certain sections of society that truth might have been. It was that time, that was the decision point for the public.

Instead, far too many news organisations and journalists seemed to be caught up in the narrative that we were a ‘nation in mourning’, and therefore actively discouraged coverage that was critical of the monarchy.

Groupthink and lack of diversity in the gatekeepers

I believe the reason this was able to happen was because the senior editors, those with decision-making power, are not diverse, and therefore subject to group-think, even if they are critical of the monarchy in theory in practice and culture they are extremely deferential (think of the way my BBC Scotland colleagues dressed for the royal visit).

The fact is, as a person who analyses media diversity, I am always suspicious when the UK is ever portrayed as a nation with a single homogeneous position or view on anything.

The UK is by definition a heterogeneous country (the clue is in the name United Kingdom) made up of four nations: England, Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland, and has a multicultural population due to being a former empire. The four nations, those with heritage from the former colonies, and, interestingly, different age groups, have very different relationships with the monarchy. The poll commissioned by Panorama at the time of the coronation only reinforced what previous polls had previously indicated.

What the people think?

A May 2022 poll by the British Future think tank indicated that only 45 per cent of respondents in Scotland positively wanted to retain the monarchy, with 36 per cent saying they thought the end of the Queen’s reign should mark the end of the monarchy altogether.

The same British Future poll showed only 40 per cent of 18 to 24-year-olds supported keeping the monarchy, and only 37 per cent of people from an ethnic minority did so. In 2021 a similar poll conducted by Panelbase found that 47 per cent of Scottish adults would vote to keep a royal head of state, compared with 35 per cent who were in favour of an elected head of state.

The story becomes even more complex once age is combined with regionality. According to a YouGov poll, also conducted in May 2022, 80 per cent of 18-30 year olds in Wales want to abolish the monarchy.

What these polls, taken well before the Queen’s death, before the King’s proclamation, and ahead of the King’s coronation, showed is that there is a sizable section of British society that do not want the monarchy to continue. The further you go from a White English, middle-aged bias, the larger this minority becomes and is even a majority in certain demographics.

Et voila, not coincidentally, it is exactly the demographic that most supports the continuation of the monarchy who are disproportionately in positions of editorial responsibility in our newsrooms.

Did the UK media reflect public opinion?

Irrespective of how well the news media has now been able to cover these opinions at the time of the ceremonial coronation, the failure to cover them impartially at the critical time of the King’s proclamation (and the monarchy’s continuation) has two serious consequences.

Firstly, it eroded the already limited trust certain demographics have in the mainstream media. At critical national moments it is vital that the whole country is represented in all its diversity. It is not good enough to say the media will only represent the whole country’s views when it is more ‘convenient’ or deferentially ‘appropriate’ to do so. That erosion in trust can push already marginalised groups, even if they are the majority, to less reputable news sources on social media that might be more prone to misinformation.

One only had to take a cursory look at #BlackTwitter or #IrishTwitter at the time of the King’s proclamation and ascension to see a range of British and non-British views on the Queen’s death that were not being reflected in mainstream UK news.

Some UK newspapers and other media outlets did, at the time of the King’s proclamation, publish opinion pieces by people from Black, Asian, and minority ethnic backgrounds that explained why they were not mourning the death of the Queen in the same way as other people in Britain. However, it is important to realise that this approach was in itself problematic, and further exacerbated the sense of ‘us and them’.

This is because it juxtaposed the supposedly ‘correct’ editorial stance (i.e. that the whole nation was mourning) which had the full weight and authority of so-called ‘impartial’ journalism with another stance relegated to being just an ‘opinion’. Moreover, commissioning these as opinion pieces risked framing any dissent from the dominant editorial stance as a ‘problem of the ethnics’, i.e. a problem with multicultural Britain, which many parts of the population are proud of.

What at first may seem like a welcome attempt to include more diversity, can instead at best lead directly to sloppy journalism and at worst exacerbate structural imbalances regarding whose opinions are heard and valued in the British national conversation.

The second consequence of the failure of impartially in reporting Charles becoming King was the creation of fundamental misunderstanding about British democracy and rights.

The best example of this was when four people were arrested in Scotland for protesting against the ascension and proclamation of King Charles III. At the time, many newspapers framed it as a ‘freedom of speech’ issue and about the ‘right to protest’. However, the journalism should have presented it as a representational issue. Why? Assuming the polls taken both before and after the Queen’s death were correct, these four protestors were representing the views of over a third of Scottish people.

The four protestors chose precisely the right time to speak ‘truth to power’ and engage in the democratic process. The newspapers framing it as a ‘right to protest’ issue essentially disenfranchised large swathes of the population and stifled an important debate. The fact that news outlets are covering dissent regarding the continuation of the monarchy now is literally too little too late for that dissenting voice to have any impact.

Not monarchist, not republican, just impartial

In these emotionally charged times I should emphasise that this is not about being a monarchist or a republican, and as an impartial journalist my own leaning has no consequence. Nor am I ignoring the fact that a large proportion of the British population were grieving at the time of the Queen’s death and King’s proclamation and ascension. This is about professional and impartial journalism, reflecting an authentic picture of the views and opinions of the entire nation back to itself and fulfilling its critical role in the democratic process of holding power to account at the most important times.

The coverage of the King’s coronation cannot be viewed in isolation. Seen in the wider context of the Queen’s death, the King’s ascension, and coverage of the royal family generally, it offers important lessons as to why diversity and inclusive representation are essential to good journalism.

Thinking back to Prince Charles’ visit to Glasgow I hope we can create newsrooms which value our highest elected officials as much as our highest unelected ones. Or at least treat each as critically as each other. More diverse newsrooms would be an important step to achieving this.


(The essay was first published in "Reporting Royalty: Analysing the Media and the Monarchy" Edited by John Mair and Andrew Beck with Richard Lance Keeble)

Tuesday, 30 May 2023

Disney’s The Little Mermaid, Caribbean Slavery, and Telling the Truth to Children


Children’s films should not ignore the more difficult parts of our history, just because adults feel uncomfortable addressing them.


The question is: How do we make films for children of all races that acknowledge the horrors of historical events such as slavery, while making sure they are free to imagine a wonderful world unencumbered by racism and are not defined by it?


On Sunday I watched the new live action version of Disney’s The Little Mermaid with my six-year-old son.


The visual effects are stunning and the casting is brilliant. If you are not aware, and at this point you would literally have to be living under a rock in the middle of the ocean not to be aware, Halle Bailey plays the eponymous heroine in a celebration of normalising Black beauty standards for children.


For my young son to see the most beautiful character in a film as a Black woman (with non-straightened hair) is important to me as a parent and goes against literally centuries of White beauty standards and societal norms. It is anti-racism at work on a deep level.


While the importance of casting the Little Mermaid as a Black woman has been commented on in numerous articles the casting of the other roles is also worth a mention. The casting is beautifully “colour blind” with the prince being White and his mother being Black (he is adopted). At the same time the Little Mermaid’s father is White while her Mermaid sisters are of various different races and ethnicities. Race as a social construct, as we know it, clearly does not exists underwater.

A world in which the very idea of race for the main characters seems to be subverted, consciously ignored, and at the same time Black beauty is celebrated, needs to be applauded.

However there is one jarring massive problem with the film and it is less about its treatment of contemporary racial issues and more about its treatment of historical transatlantic slavery.


The film is set in the Caribbean in the 18th century. It does not specify exactly when, but judging from the ships, clothes and other references it is during a time of African chattel slavery. And yet there is not a single direct reference to slavery and the islanders live in racial harmony. 


In this setting, I do not think we do our children any favours by pretending that slavery didn’t exist. For me Disney’s preference to try and wish the inconvenient truth away says more about the adult creatives than it does about children’s ability to work through it.


The enslavement of Africans in the Americas (across the southern states of the US, Caribbean and South America) in the 18th century was a brutal time and has been described by some historians and commentators as a “holocaust”, a crime against humanity that is so heinous that there are calls to this day for reparations to compensate the descendants of the victims.


Setting the fantastical story in this time and place is literally the equivalent of setting a love story between Jew and Gentile in 1940 Germany and ignoring the Jewish holocaust. Or possibly more accurately setting it in a slave plantation in America’s antebellum south and pretending the enslaved Africans were happy.


The 18th century Caribbean is a problematic time to set any children’s story, but that should make it full of creative possibilities as opposed to encouraging historical amnesia.


First of all, I do not need every story and movie that my 6-year-old consumes to be historically accurate. The appearance of steel pans in the film, an instrument invented in the late 1930s, raised a wry smile in the pedant in me, but I found it easy enough to overlook. But the total erasure and rewriting of one of the most painful and important parts of African diasporic history, is borderline dangerous, especially when it is consumed unquestioningly by children. I do not want my child to think that the Caribbean in the 18th century was a time of racial harmony, any more than I suspect a Jewish father wants his child to think 1940 Germany was a time of religious tolerance, however much we might both wish they were. 


So does this mean Black children cannot have escapist fantasies of the past, or all our historical stories have to overtly address racism and slavery? 


Definitely not.


I want my Black son to be as free, joyful and unencumbered by horrors of history just as much as any of his White and Asian friends at school, but I also do not want him, (or any children) to be given a false view of history on key issues - slavery being one of them.


There are several ways in which Disney could have easily set The Little Mermaid story in the Caribbean in the 18th century and not whitewashed (excuse the pun) the importance of history.


For example they could have set the story in Haiti post-1804. Haiti was the first Caribbean country to throw off the shackles of slavery and most importantly in its constitution of 1805 explicitly denounces the idea of different “races” proclaiming true equality. According to Julia Gaffield, a professor of history at Georgia State University, the constitution even “explicitly acknowledged that some ‘white women,’ Germans, and Poles had been naturalized as Haitian citizens highlighting the radical reconceptualization of race that underpinned Haiti’s entry on the world stage.”


In this scenario the Little Mermaid could have easily found her prince, while race and slavery could have been gently touched upon without being overbearing or having to show the horrors. A post revolutionary Haiti would have been the perfect setting for an island of racial harmony, and in doing so it would have gently educated children about an important period in world history.


When we think creatively and know our Caribbean history there are numerous solutions to setting the story in the Caribbean during the time of slavery while neither wanting to erase our history or expose children to the full horrors of chattel slavery. As someone of Jamaican heritage I would have loved the Little Mermaid to fall in love with a Maroon (a runaway slave), although that would have required her to swim a little upstream towards the island's interior.


We owe it to our children to give them the most amazing fantastical stories possible to help their imaginations grow. We do not do this by “whitewashing” out the difficult parts of our history. We do it by embracing our rich history and empowering them with the truth. Next time I hope Disney can be as adventurous with its story telling as it was with its casting.


Tuesday, 23 May 2023

ChatGPT is an existential threat to media diversity



ChatGPT is an existential threat to media diversity.

To understand why it is important to understand why is diversity in the media and creative industry so important. And who better to ask than Chat GPT itself: 

Question to ChatGPT's Open AI - Why is media diversity important?

Answer by ChatGPT's Open AI - Media diversity is important for several reasons: 
 
1. Representation: Media diversity ensures that different voices, perspectives, and experiences are represented. It allows for a more accurate reflection of the diverse societies in which we live. When media outlets showcase a range of races, ethnicities, genders, sexual orientations, religions, and abilities, it helps combat stereotypes, promotes inclusivity, and empowers marginalized communities. 

2. Pluralism: Media diversity fosters a pluralistic society by exposing individuals to a wide range of ideas, opinions, and viewpoints. It encourages critical thinking, open dialogue, and the exploration of different perspectives. A diverse media landscape helps to prevent the dominance of a single narrative or ideology, allowing for a more informed and balanced public discourse. 

3. Democracy and civic participation: A diverse media ecosystem is crucial for a healthy democracy. It ensures that citizens have access to a variety of information sources, enabling them to make informed decisions and participate meaningfully in civic life. When media outlets represent a broad range of interests, they can hold governments, institutions, and powerful individuals accountable, fostering transparency and good governance. 

4. Social cohesion: Media diversity contributes to social cohesion by promoting understanding, empathy, and unity among diverse groups. By portraying a range of experiences and identities, the media can bridge divides and create a sense of shared humanity. It helps challenge prejudices, reduce discrimination, and build a more inclusive society where everyone feels valued and respected. 

5. Economic and cultural benefits: A diverse media industry can have economic and cultural benefits. It creates opportunities for diverse content creators, journalists, and artists, allowing them to share their talents and stories with a broader audience. This, in turn, promotes innovation, creativity, and cultural exchange, enriching society as a whole. 

In summary, media diversity is essential for representation, pluralism, democracy, social cohesion, and economic/cultural benefits. It ensures that the media landscape reflects the realities of diverse societies, amplifies different voices and perspectives, and facilitates a more inclusive and informed public discourse. 

Far too often the debate around media diversity is framed in terms of point five, the need to employ more Black and Asian people in the industry at different levels, or employing more women, disabled people, LGBTQ+ (insert the protected characteristic / underrepresented demographic here).

While increasing the employment prospects and career progression of all these different groups is important it fundamentally misses the other four points and puts media diversity on par with increasing diversity in any other industry or sector; from double glazing to medicinal chemist (just for the record some of my best friends work in double glazing and I once dated a medicinal chemist).

What ChatGPT so beautifully explains is the idea that media diversity is about so much more than employing a few more Black and Asian people in the media industry at different levels, or employing more women, disabled people, LGBTQ+ (insert the protected characteristic / underrepresented demographic here).

While increasing the employment prospects and career progression of all these different groups is important it fundamentally misses the point and puts media diversity on par with increasing diversity in any other industry or sector; from double glazing to marine biologists.

The importance of media diversity is unique and it goes to the very heart of how we function as a society.

And this is precisely why ChatGPT is an existential threat to media diversity.

If we believe media diversity is about freedom of speech, democratic discourse, and who is empowered to contribute to the narrative that society tells about itself and the rest of the world.

Fundamentally if we believe in representational democracy, we must fight for representational story telling. Because it is the stories we tell, both fiction and non-fiction, that shapes our understanding of the world, our values, our beliefs, and how our democracy works.

ChatGPT and other forms of AI are an existential threat to that.

ChatGPT creates text and stories (fiction and non-fiction) which are then used by students, authors, scriptwriters and journalists as a first draft which they can edit, or to supplement their own existing work. (In the future it may not even support the work of creatives but replace them)

The problem is ChatGPT is “White, non-disabled, heterosexual and male”. In that the source text that ChatGPT’s algorithms draw on are disproportionately written by white, non-disabled, heterosexual men.

This should hardly be surprising for anyone who works in the field of media diversity. It is already known that white, non-disabled, heterosexual men are disproportionately over-represented in areas such as journalism, literature, film and theatre.

By drawing on the current source materials ChatGPT will by definition amplify the already existing inequalities of the narratives, values and views of white, non-disabled, heterosexual men being over-represented.

Let me illustrate this with one simple example:

In 2020 the Press Gazette published research by Women in Journalism, showing that in one week in July 2020 - at the height of the Black Lives Matter protests across the world - UK’s 11 biggest newspapers failed to feature a single byline by black journalist on their front pages. Taking non-white journalists as whole of the 174 bylines examined only 4 were credited to journalists of colour.

The same report also found that in the same week just one in four front-page bylines across the 11 papers went to women.

Importantly the week the study surveyed the biggest news stories were about Covid-19, Black Lives Matter, the replacement of the toppled statue of the slave trader Edward Colston in Bristol and the appeal over the British citizenship of the Muslim mother, Shamima Begum.

Assuming ChatGPT's algorithm draws on the stories written by journalists in mainstream newspapers to generate its text, if you ask it any questions about the news that week you will literally be hearing from the voices of White men; White men writing about issues that disproportionately impact people of colour.

If you do not see this as a problem then I strongly suspect you are reading the wrong blog.

The question, for those of us interested in media diversity, is what do we do now?

I do not believe the answer is to simply disengage from ChatGPT and hope it goes away. Instead we have to find ways to engage constructively and find ways for journalists, and other creatives, to use ChatGPT in ways which do not effectively silence, or further marginalises, already under-represented groups.

This is incredibly new territory and I don't think anyone has all the answers of how to do this, but that doesn't mean we shouldn't try.


I am calling on journalists and creatives to join me in creating a manifesto, a simple set of guidelines, of how we should work with ChatGPT constructively and what we should be demanding of the tech companies who create these programmes.

This issue is too important to leave it up to or other people to work out the solutions. (My DM's are open @marcusryder)


Wednesday, 3 May 2023

World Press Freedom Day is Meaningless Without Media Diversity




Today, Wednesday, May 3rd, 2023 is World Press Freedom Day. The purpose of the day, (now in its 30th year) is to raise awareness about the value of press freedom, the necessity of defending journalists' rights, and the need to support independent, free media.

The most recent report on press freedoms by the World Press Freedom Index revealed a shocking decline in press freedoms across the world, with a record 31 countries being in a “very serious situation”, the lowest rank in the report, up from 21 just two years ago. The list, released by Reporters Without Borders (RSF), also saw the UK fall from 24th in the global rankings last year to 26th this year.

My concern, as a Black British journalist, is that the UK’s position might be even worse for people of colour working (or more specifically failing to work) in the industry.


Freedom of the press means nothing if large sections of the population are denied access to it.


According to the Reuters Institute, only about 0.2% of British journalists are Black


In 2020 the Press Gazette published research by Women in Journalism, showing that in one week in July 2020 - at the height of the Black Lives Matter protests across the world  - UK’s 11 biggest newspapers failed to feature a single byline by a black journalist on their front pages. And of the 174 front page bylines examined in that period only 4 were credited to journalists of colour.

 

The same report also found that in the same week just one in four front-page bylines across the 11 papers went to women.

 

It should be noted that the week the study surveyed featured front page stories about Black Lives Matter, the replacement of the toppled statue of the slave trader Edward Colston in Bristol and the appeal over the British citizenship of the Muslim mother, Shamima Begum.


Front page stories frame how the public view an issue with many never getting past the headline. 


A recent report by the Ethical Journalism Network also found that anti-black racism in UK newsrooms is “commonplace”. 


And finally there is not one single major television news bulletin from the BBC’s Breakfast News, One O’clock, Six O’clock or Ten O’clock to Channel 4’s Seven O’Clock to any of ITV’s major bulletins or Channel 5s which is headed by a person of colour or a visibly disabled person.


For clarity I am not talking about the people in front of the camera – I am talking about the executives and editors behind the camera, the people with real power who decide which stories are covered and how. 


Today, in newsrooms across Britain – whether print, online or on TV - it is primarily white, non-disabled, heterosexual men, in London who are deciding what issues news organisations should cover and how they should be covered.


This is a damning indictment of the very principle of Press Freedom, if Black people are not able to tell their stories or are relegated to minor coverage - even about stories that directly affect us such as the #BLM protests - we do not have a free press.


This is not a freedom that is being curtailed by “evil” governments targeting the press, which is how many of the stories about World Press Freedom Day are framed. This is a press freedom that is being curtailed by the inner workings of the newsrooms themselves.


When we write and discuss World Press Freedom Day we must recognise that diversity and inclusion are not viewed as a side issue, but are essential to the very press freedoms all journalists should hold dear..


It is important that we should all fight for press freedoms across the world, but in doing so we must not forget those closest to home who are also seeing their freedoms curtailed.


Sunday, 23 April 2023

Diane Abbott, antisemitism and an important lesson for journalists



The current furore around Diane Abbott MP and accusations of antisemitism, in which she equated the prejudice Jewish people face with the prejudice faced by redheads, hold important lessons for journalists covering the issues of diversity, inclusion, equality, racism and (of course) antisemitism.

To explain, let me start with a story.

A few years ago I was talking to a young black girl about the prejudice women face. She earnestly turned to me and said “I understand it, it’s like racism against women”. I fought back a laugh and replied, “yes, it’s called 'sexism'.”

The beauty of the English language is that it is incredibly rich with the largest vocabulary of any language.

We have a specific term for the prejudice and bigotry that women face; “sexism”, and that in turn is different from “misogyny”.

We do Jewish people a disservice if we simply refer to the prejudice and bigotry they face as “racism”. It is “antisemitism”.

Race as we understand it is a social construct which was effectively “invented” during colonialism and transatlantic slavery. It was invented long after the long history of the prejudice, persecution and bigotry Jewish people face began, which dates back millennia. Therefore, logically the term “racism” is historically incorrect and doesn’t fully capture what Jewish people experience.

It should be noted at this point that “race” is different from “ethnicity”, that is the beauty of English, it is able to capture these nuances.

“Antisemitism” is different from “Islamophobia”, and both are different from “sectarianism”.

We do the different and difficult issues that different people face a disservice if we describe it all as “racism”. We also do a disservice to the great English language.

Diane Abbott was completely wrong to describe the prejudice that Travellers and Jewish people face as equivalent to the prejudice and bigotry redheaded people face, it was crass, offensive, and it was right for her to apologise.

When I read her original letter to the Observer, what I understood her underlying message to be; that the “racism” black people face and “antisemitism” are not the same, it is a message I have sympathy with, or at the very least one which I believe should be discussed openly and calmly. Saying one is more or less important than the other is not one I have any sympathy with.

And herein lies an important lesson for journalists. We need to be precise in our language. We should not create false equivalence or hierarchies of victimhood, or we end up offending everyone.

When a journalist asks the seemingly simple question; "Are Jewish people white?" it is giving far too much credit, (and logic) to a system to classify people which was born out of prejudice and illogicality. For me the 'racial' status of Jewish people beautifully expose the lie that race actually makes any sense at all.  As one Jewish friend once said to me, when I naively asked the same question; "Jewish people are the Schrödinger's cat of racism, we are both white and not white at the same time".

Antisemitism is terrible and needs to be addressed. Islamophobia is terrible and needs to be addressed. Racism is terrible and needs to be addressed.

But we cannot properly fight them if we think they are all one and the same thing. Or as my young friend, at the beginning of this piece did, using the same lens and framing to understand different forms of prejudice.

The English language gives us the tools to properly describe, understand and analyse the world around us in all its beauty and ugliness.
  
And that is why, as both a journalist and some one who strives to increase media diversity, I love English. 

Monday, 27 March 2023

DIVERSITY FAILINGS AT THE HEART OF BBC’S IMPARTIALITY WOES


Diversity needs to be at the centre of any review into BBC’s impartiality and guidelines on the use of social media.

On Monday 11th March the BBC’s Director General, Tim Davie, announced that an independent review will be carried out on examining the corporation's social media guidelines.

On Sunday 26th March the Labour Party announced its own BBC review panel. The brief of Labour’s panel covers several areas ahead of the BBC’s next charter renewal in 2027, but again one of the key issues is impartiality.

Even before they start it is easy to pick holes and be cynical about both proposed reviews:

How independent can a review into the BBC really be when the BBC itself sets up the terms of reference and will decide who sits on it?

Can a Labour review with three of the announced four members heavily associated with the Party (James Purnell, Lou Cordwell and June Sarpong) really be expected to be free of bias when reviewing issues such as impartiality and political interference?

The announcement of both reviews come in the wake of the Gary Linekar Twitter controversy, where the BBC initially suspended him for Tweeting about the government’s rhetoric around immigration only to reinstate him less than a week later. Irrespective of any criticisms of how either review has been set up or will operate, what they clearly point to is the growing need for a review into the BBC’s editorial guidelines, with specific reference to how it interprets and implements the principle of “due impartiality”.

However, what most people seem to be missing in all the discussions around BBC impartiality is the centrality of diversity.

Over the last three and a half years the BBC has made four major public editorial U-turns around the issue of impartiality. All four of them have been about diversity and/or minoritised groups:

In October 2019 the BBC reversed its ruling that Breakfast News presenter, Naga Munchetty, had broken editorial guidelines when discussing whether one of President Trump’s Tweets was racist.

In August 2020 the BBC finally apologised for one of its news reporters using the N-word after initially defending the decision.

In October 2020, in what the BBC described as a “clarification” as opposed to a “U-turn”, the corporation said that staff would be allowed to attend Pride marches and this would not compromise their impartiality after initially saying they would not.

And finally in March 2023, the BBC made - what was seen by most - as a U-turn when it initially suspended Gary Linekar over his Tweets about the government’s rhetoric around immigration, only to reinstate him less than a week later. (The BBC was at pains to describe this not as a “climb-down” but “proportionate action).

All four editorial issues have the issue of diversity and inclusion at their core. The first two being obviously racial issues, the third being about LGBTQ+ rights and the fourth, immigration, being a heavily racialised subject.

The biggest problem that the BBC has, when it comes to its editorial guidelines in general, and “due impartiality” in particular, is diversity.

It is the editorial issue literally hiding in plain sight.

This is about how a centralised organisation, which is meant to represent the whole of the UK, fairly represents the concerns and interests of, and about, minority groups while maintaining due impartiality. I saw this problem close up with regards to regional diversity when I was head of BBC Scotland Current Affairs in 2014 covering the Scottish Independence referendum. The fall out of which the BBC is still suffering from.

We do need to set up an independent review into BBC’s editorial guidelines and impartiality, but unless diversity is at the very centre of the review it will fail irrespective of who sits on it.

Thursday, 2 March 2023

Award ceremonies reveal the uncomfortable truth of British journalism


Last night I attended the Royal Television Society (RTS) Television Journalism Awards. Having sat on one of the judging panels, I was keen not only to find out about the results of our lengthy deliberations (the final votes are by secret ballot) but having been unable to attend the prestigious ceremony for several years due to COVID-19 I was also interested to see “IRL” how the industry I have spent almost thirty years in is faring, especially in terms of reflecting diversity.

 

Those of you who know me will know that I believe diversity is essential to strong journalism – and has been especially essential this past year with British coverage of key events under significant domestic and global scrutiny – from the Ukraine war to the death of Queen Elizabeth. Indeed, over the last year we have seen examples of UK and international journalism making serious mistakes, precisely because of a lack of diversity.

 

Spoiler alert: I can’t say that I came away from the RTS ceremony last night feeling better about the current state of the industry.

 

In many ways, I should have known. There are vastly different perceptions of progress on diversity in the industry, and those who are in the public eye seem to be focused on creating a narrative of progress.

 

A few hours before the award ceremony I had been in a briefing call with another television and news veteran. They will be hosting an event I have agreed to participate in, focused on diversity in broadcast journalism. During the briefing, the host asked me to focus on the “positives” that we should be talking about as “we don’t want to be too critical”.


At the RTS ceremony itself, I was honoured to be sat on the same table as one the most powerful people in British television. The senior executive was eager to convey how well their particular organisation is doing when it came to racial and gender diversity, both in the level of their employees overall, and at senior management. The executive did admit with some regret that levels of disability are very low, but this was caveated with the idea that the actual level might be higher and there is a problem of “people not wanting to declare that they are disabled”.


I recognised this narrative. In 2012, I convened my first RTS Diversity Committee meeting, and was assuaged by an executive about their particular broadcaster: “You know, if you look at our staff diversity numbers, they are really rather good, but our disability numbers are not good.” Sadly, this was not true, and over time it was revealed that the organisation was simply using metrics that gave them the results they wanted to believe to be true.

 

I wondered if the ceremony, then, would reveal the change since 2012.

 

There are some pieces which suggest a potential shift. The BBC recently promoted Ravin Sampat to the position of executive news editor with a brief to oversee UK story teams, and Lebanese-born Lilian Landor was appointed Director of the BBC World Service in 2021. While at ITN, there have been similar key appointments at ITV News, and the Sir Lenny Henry Centre for Media Diversity, (who I work for) were heavily involved in working with Channel 4 on its  “Black to Front” project which not only highlighted the non-White talent at Channel 4 News but also helped progress certain careers afterwards

 

However, in the infamous words of Lenny Henry commenting on the Bafta Television awards in 2013, it soon became apparent that the RTS Television Journalism Awards 2023 would be; “all White on the night”.

 

Many of the awards, such as Network Daily News Programme of the Year, went to entire production teams, meaning there were often several people on stage at a time. A lot the teams had a smattering of people of colour. And of course, it is impossible to always know someone’s race and ethnicity just by looking at them, and so sitting in the audience one cannot say for certain what the race and ethnicity of all the winners was.

 

But with the notable exception of Clive Myrie, who won Network Presenter of the Year, almost every person who accepted an award and gave the acceptance speech – even on behalf of the teams – appeared to be White. There was just one person who had a visible disability, Jeremy Paxman, winner of Lifetime Outstanding Contribution Award, who needed to be assisted onto the stage.


Three quarters of the way through the ceremony another person sitting on my table, a former senior television executive, leaned over and whispered in my ear; “Marcus, they are ALL White”.  Later, a respected media commentator who had been present messaged me: “Good to see you tonight. I was utterly shocked how White that event was. Quite incredible”.

 

Clive Myrie’s win was notable and it is important to recognise his contribution to television journalism in the last year. He has been a mainstay on British and international screens with the reporting of the Ukraine war. However, he comes in a long line of single news presenters of colour being the exception in an otherwise predominately White industry. The likes of Trevor McDonald, Rageh Omaar and Krishnan Guru-Murthy - all great journalists, reporters and presenters who rightly deserve the numerous awards they have received over the years - are Myrie’s predecessors in more than one way. This means that while Myrie’s achievements should be seen as impressive on an individual basis, they cannot be seen as an indication of progress in terms of increasing racial diversity in newsrooms.

 

What the RTS television journalism award ceremony seemed to reveal, in fact, is one overarching, and slightly uncomfortable, truth.

 

That while there has been some progress in terms of newsroom diversity, the journalism that is most respected and valued by the industry; the journalists that cover the biggest news stories; the journalism that commands the largest budgets; and the journalism that shapes national British debates and frames the way Brits view the world remains overwhelmingly the preserve of White people. In this respect, there has been almost no progress in over twenty years.

 

But here is what really kept me from sleeping as I returned to my warm bed last night.

Awards ceremonies always have winners and losers. Emotions are always high, even when it comes to journalism awards, despite our well-known stoicism. But it was the huge gap between the desire to be optimistic and self-congratulatory of many when it comes to diversity, versus the private realism and shock of others in the room – whether White, Black, disabled or able-bodied – that was incredibly stark.

 

Perhaps most remarkably, it was the fact that those who have the opportunity and potential to change this, far too many of them appear to be in denial, truthfully or otherwise, of how poor the industry’s diversity problem is, and how little substantive progress has been made in the last few decades.

 

The ultimate question has to be, “Can there ever be real change?”

 

The answer to that has to be a resounding “Yes”, but only if we acknowledge the position we are in right now, and that continuing the policies that have failed to bring about real progress will not do it. To quote Albert Einstein "Insanity is doing the same thing over and over and expecting different results."